In the heart of Amish country lies a quaint bed and breakfast with secrets thicker than a shoo-fly pie. When elderly Amish widow Ettie Smith and her sister are whisked into the world of wedding catering, little did they know their duties would soon expand to investigating a murder.
Before the newlyweds could even churn their marital bliss, the groom ends up deader than last season's corn crop on the library floor. The prime suspect? Thomas, the B&B co-owner, who's forgotten more than just his manners-it seems his memory of the murder has churned into butter. Add a dollop of suspicious antics in the mix, and Ettie and her sister find themselves knee-deep in a mystery that threatens to leave a sour taste. Undeterred, they pledge to rise to the occasion, buttering up a grumpy detective as they knead the clues.