"An important contribution to the study of mental illness, gender roles, and family interaction. . . . An insightful and well-written book demonstrating the pervasive consequences of gender roles for the deepest levels of mind and emotion."--American Journal of Sociology "Opens a window onto the lives of the mentally ill and their families."--Women's Review of Books "Warren's analysis is painstaking and illuminating, and there is plenty of material here to interest those concerned with issues of gender and mental illness."--Times Higher Education Supplement "The women make the author's major points in riveting fashion, speaking eloquently of enforced dependency and subjugation, the helplessness of rigid and constantly reinforced gender-role boundaries, and outright manipulation by their husbands."--Contemporary Psychology "Can marriage make women go crazy? Carol Warren addresses this question by emphasizing the connections between gender-sterotypical behavior and the institutionalization of married women in the 1950s, using interviews collected . . . during 1957-61. . . . An interesting sociological reworking of the original pychologically oriented interpretation of the interviews."--Oral History Review Carol A. B. Warren is a professor of sociology at the University of Kansas and author of The Court of Last Resort: Mental Illness and the Law.
First of all, learn what "sociological" means. This is not a psychology or a psychiatry book. If that's what you're looking for, go read the DSM IV or something. This is a sociological book, which means that it's going to explore the connections between some phenomenon and its social (and in this case, historical) context. Warren is going beyong the diagnoses these women received to examine what was REALLY going on with them and their society at the time. Most of these women were NOT really schizophrenic, but were labeled as such because they were "problematic" for their husbands or their society for some other reason. It's great--read it, and then think about how much trust we implicitly put in our doctors and other medical and mental health practitioners just because they are professionals.
A must read for future clinicians!
Published by Thriftbooks.com User , 23 years ago
As a future clinical psychologist, I see it as my responsibility to not take past abuses of the field lightly. This book is a reminder that, whatever one's motivations, to carry the title of "psychologist" entitles one to a great degree of power over the lives of others. Despite what my fellow reviewer wrote, Warren makes no claims that the field has gone stagnant. Her critique of psychiatry and institutionalization as forms of social control is powerful and insightful. To paraphrase the old adage, those ignorant of the past are doomed to repeat it. If only for this reason, this is a must read for clinicians of any background.
ThriftBooks sells millions of used books at the lowest everyday prices. We personally assess every book's quality and offer rare, out-of-print treasures. We deliver the joy of reading in recyclable packaging with free standard shipping on US orders over $15. ThriftBooks.com. Read more. Spend less.