Three years ago Beth nearly lost her sister, Nora, at the hands of a madwoman. Ever since she's been plagued by nightmares that force her to relive that horrific deal.
Now, it seems they are becoming a reality once more. On the third anniversary of the tragedy that shook their small New York town, Beth starts finding tokens and trinkets planted in places only she would find them. It seems the debate is over and someone wants to play a twisted game.